Buildium vs PayHOA for HOA boards (2026)
TLDR
Buildium costs $1.50-$3/unit/month. A 200-unit HOA pays $300-$600/month. PayHOA runs $49-$199/month flat with no unit pricing. PayHOA is almost always cheaper for self-managed communities, and it is built for HOAs rather than property managers.
| Feature | Buildium | PayHOA | BoardStack |
|---|---|---|---|
| Monthly cost | $1.50-$3/unit/mo | $49-$199/mo | $20–$99/mo |
| Reserve fund compliance | No | No | Built-in, state-specific |
| Built for | Professional management | Professional management | Volunteer boards |
Get notified when BoardStack launches
Join the waitlist for early access and reserve fund compliance tools built for self-managed HOA boards.
The pricing model difference
Buildium uses per-unit pricing: $1.50-$3/unit/month depending on your plan tier. For a 100-unit HOA, that is $150-$300/month. For 300 units, $450-$900/month. The cost scales directly with community size, which is reasonable for professional property managers billing costs to clients. For a self-managed HOA paying out of dues, it adds up fast.
PayHOA uses flat monthly tiers starting at $49/month. The higher tiers cover more features, not more units. A 300-unit HOA on PayHOA pays the same as a 100-unit HOA on the same tier. For self-managed communities, flat pricing is almost always cheaper once you have more than 50-75 units.
Who each tool is built for
Buildium’s design assumes a property management company running dozens of properties for multiple owner-clients. The reporting structure, the owner vs. tenant distinctions, the multi-property portfolio view: all of it assumes that context. Volunteer HOA board members who open the software once a month for a treasurer report find the interface confusing.
PayHOA is built for HOAs specifically. The terminology is right: homeowners, not tenants. The board structure is explicit. The violation workflow matches HOA enforcement processes. For a volunteer treasurer handling their own community’s finances, PayHOA is easier to navigate.
Features both tools share
Both have:
- Online dues collection with ACH and credit card
- Basic accounting and financial reports
- Owner portals for document access and payment history
- Violation tracking with letter generation
- Document storage for governing documents
The execution quality differs in the details. Buildium’s mobile app gets poor ratings, an issue when board members want to check something on a phone. PayHOA’s mobile experience is better.
What both tools miss
Neither Buildium nor PayHOA tracks reserve fund compliance. Both let you record transactions to a reserve fund account, but neither connects your reserve balance to a reserve study target, flags underfunding risk, or generates the reserve status reports state law may require.
BoardStack is built around reserve compliance. If your board needs visibility into reserve fund adequacy (not just what the balance is today, but whether you are on track to meet your obligations), that is the gap BoardStack was designed to fill.
| Feature | Buildium | PayHOA |
|---|---|---|
| HOA-specific design | Partial (property management focus) | Yes |
| Reserve fund accounting | No | No |
| Operating/reserve fund separation | No | No |
| Pricing model | Per unit ($1.50-$3/unit/mo) | Flat tiers ($49-$199/mo) |
| 100-unit monthly cost | $150-$300/mo | $99/mo |
| Online dues collection | Yes | Yes |
| Violation tracking | Yes | Yes |
| Mobile app quality | Poor ratings | Better ratings |
PROS & CONS
Buildium
Pros
- No unit minimum — small associations can sign up
- Broad accounting features including general ledger and owner reports
- Established platform with a long track record
Cons
- Per-unit pricing grows expensive as community size increases
- Steep learning curve for volunteers logging in monthly
- No reserve fund compliance tracking
PROS & CONS
PayHOA
Pros
- Flat pricing that does not scale with unit count
- Purpose-built for HOA boards with appropriate terminology
- Easier interface for volunteer board members
Cons
- No reserve fund compliance tracking
- Less accounting depth than Buildium for complex needs
- Fewer integrations with external accounting tools
Is Buildium or PayHOA better for self-managed HOA boards?
PayHOA is the better fit for most self-managed HOA boards. It uses flat pricing (not per-unit), is built specifically for HOAs rather than property managers, and has a simpler interface for volunteers. Buildium's per-unit pricing makes it more expensive for communities above 50 units, and its property management focus adds complexity that volunteer boards do not need.
How does Buildium's per-unit pricing compare to PayHOA for a 200-unit HOA?
A 200-unit HOA pays $300-$600/month on Buildium at $1.50-$3/unit/month. The same community pays $199/month on PayHOA's top flat tier. PayHOA saves $100-$400/month at that size.
Do Buildium or PayHOA separate operating and reserve funds?
Neither Buildium nor PayHOA separates operating and reserve funds as distinct fund accounts by default. Both require manual chart-of-accounts configuration to approximate fund accounting, and neither tracks reserve funding levels against reserve study targets.
Verdict
PayHOA is the better fit for self-managed HOA boards: lower cost, simpler interface, and purpose-built for the HOA context. Buildium's per-unit pricing and property management focus make it a poor match. For reserve fund compliance on top of core management, BoardStack ($20–$99/mo flat) adds what PayHOA lacks.
Is Buildium or PayHOA better for small HOAs?
How does Buildium's per-unit pricing add up?
Does Buildium have fund accounting for HOAs?
Ready to protect your board?
Get started free- State-specific compliance
- No setup fees
- Flat $20–$99/month
Related Comparisons
Best Buildium Alternative for Self-Managed HOAs
Buildium's per-unit pricing costs $300-$600/mo for a 200-unit HOA. Self-managed boards overpay for rental management features. BoardStack charges flat rates from $20/mo with HOA-specific tools.
Best PayHOA Alternative for Self-Managed HOAs
PayHOA handles payments well but lacks reserve fund tools and state compliance features. BoardStack gives self-managed boards reserve tracking and liability protection at $20–$99/mo.
HOA reserve fund compliance guide
Which states mandate reserve studies, what those requirements mean for your board, and how to fix your accounting to separate operating and reserve funds.